NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger


10 thoughts on “NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger

  1. says: NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger

    Free read The Ego Tunnel NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger Never mind that Buddhist philosophers have pointed out the ultimate nonexistence of the self for about twenty five centurie

  2. says: NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters This is uite simply one of the best books on consciousness I've ever read I really want to do this book justice with a fantastic review and I don't know if that's possible But I'm going to do my best Consciousness is really the last frontier of neuroscience and philosophyholy grail might be a apt terminology S

  3. says: Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger I have a psychology background so I am deeply interested in neuroscience and AI research I've even read Metzinger several times in the past ranking him up there with Dennet and also a number of bleeding edge modern philosophers So

  4. says: NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger

    Free read The Ego Tunnel Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger I am going to demonstrate the inferiority of your intelligence to you by spouting fantastically complex and seemingly endless sentences They will make your short term buffer collapse because you cannot integrate th

  5. says: Free read The Ego Tunnel Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger I approached this book thinking it would be an integration of philosophy and neuroscience I was wrong and disappointed Metzinger philosopher by profession seems to explain consciousness as in chiefly philosophical terms supporting his argument by cherry picked cognitive neuroscience findings This cherry picking is what angered me the most especially when combined with the moral high ground from which the author a field of science in which

  6. says: NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Free read The Ego Tunnel Having long since come to the conclusion that 'self' is is right up there with souls gods and angels I saw The Ego Tunnel as the an opportunity to explore where philosophy and neuroscience were on the subject While I would

  7. says: NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger Free read The Ego Tunnel

    Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters science fiction writers will enjoy this book for the rest of us it's poppycock i'll never get those hours back i felt i HAD

  8. says: Free read The Ego Tunnel Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger I obstinately resist the tunnel metaphor insisting on a bubble metaphor Now after thinking about this web concept based on Google's page rank technology I am picturing an Ego Web a multidimensional highly complex node inte

  9. says: Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger I decided to read this because Metzinger's philosophy of consciousness is discussed at great length in Thomas Ligotti's The Conspiracy Against the Human Race which is a book I am always trying to better understand I'm fascinated by

  10. says: Free read The Ego Tunnel Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters

    NEW The Ego Tunnel Þ Thomas Metzinger Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Metzinger is obviously very well informed about the latest research in consciousness The most valuable part of this book is his synthesis of this research into his theory of the “ego tunnel” He provides a plausible step by step argument for how the brain generates the mind For that alone the book is worth reading However the book has some major problems It could be that some of these problems arise because of Metzing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Free read The Ego Tunnel

characters ↠ The Ego Tunnel è PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger We’re used to thinking about the self as an independent entity something that we either have or are In The Ego Tunnel philosopher Thomas Metzinger claims otherwise No such thing as a self exists The conscious self is the content of a mod. This is uite simply one of the best books on consciousness I ve ever read I really want to do this book justice with a fantastic review and I don t know if that s possible But I m going to do my best Consciousness is really the last frontier of neuroscience and philosophyholy grail might be a apt terminology Sure there are lots of other unanswered uestions in the sciences but besides maybe some uestions about the fundamental makeup of our universe we at least know HOW to go about answering these uestions A comprehensive theory of consciousness has eluded us precisely because even trying to frame the uestion properly has proven difficult What exactly is consciousness Is it wakefulness Is it awareness Intentionality Representation Subjective experience Neuroscience has been slowly chipping away at the problem And one thing you will often hear from neuroscientists and even some philosophers has to do with finding the neural correlates of consciousness It s been neuroscientific dogma for some time now that neuronal firing is what leads to and causes conscious experience This is not an easy statement to disagree with It seems obvious Patterns of neuronal firing represent our sensory information our memories our emotions Block neuronal firing in some areas of the brain and your conscious experience is changed Mental states brain states and brain states neuronal firing And yet there is something that is being ignored here Namely there is nothing inherent in the description of neuronal firing let alone any physical processes to explain HOW and WHY neuronal firing causes subjective phenomenal experience This is what is called the explanatory gap in philosophy We can all imagine an organism or even a robot with the same functional euivalence of systems and processes without the subjective experience that goes along with it A very complicated computer There is nothing in the laws of physics or chemistry or biology that lead to the prediction that collections of certain types of matter will experience consciousness no matter how complex they are Why do I experience anything Why is there even a me And here is where an important point comes in Neuroscience has also chipped away at many classical ideas of what a self is I ve always had the sneaking suspicion that the hard problems of consciousness were in some way inextricably tied to the concept of a self Without stating this explicitly this is exactly where Metzinger s starting point is The Ego Tunnel is Metzinger s attempt at explaining both consciousness and the self Why is consciousness subjective What is the self What exactly is it that is reading this book review right now Metzinger doesn t beat around the bush and straight off states that there are no such things as and never have been any selves in the world And the metaphor Metzinger uses to explain how this is the Ego TunnelWhat is the Ego Tunnel No one can be told what the Ego Tunnel is you have to experience it for yourself Just kiddingThe ego tunnel is a selective way of representing information What we see and hear and feel and smell and taste is only a small fraction of what exists out there in the world Our conscious model of reality if you don t understand that all we experience is a model of reality this book may not be the best starting point is a low dimensional projection of an inconceivably richer physical reality surrounding us Our sensory organs are limited they evolved for survival not for depicting objective reality And so the ongoing process of conscious experience is not so much an image of reality as a tunnel through it Whenever our brains succeed in creating this unified and dynamic portrait of reality we become conscious And when the organism can generate an inner image of itself as a whole including the body psychological states relationships to the past and future this internal image is what Metzinger calls the phenomenal ego An I A self A Phenomenal Self Model By placing this self model within the world a center is created which is experienced as a self as a me and is what Metzinger calls the Ego TunnelThere are six problems the Metzinger sees in developing a comprehensive theory of consciousness1 The one world problem or the unity of conscious experienceThis has also been called the binding problem But it is basically the problem of how so many disparate processes in the brain combine to create the unity of one world There is no one place in the brain where all the different parts of the visual signal combine and form into a picture there is no one place in the brain where sight and sound and smell and taste all combine to create a unified sensory experience there is no one place where these senses combine with memory and emotion and cognition to create the unified experience of consciousness Yet it happens Francis Crick and Christof Koch suggested that this binding happens through the oscillation of the relevant neurons at something like 40 70hz Metzinger runs with this theory talking about a cloud of neuronal firing Whatever is in the cloud is conscious information And whatever isn t isn t This binding of various processes allows the world to appear to us 2 The now problem the appearance of a lived momentAn image of a world alone is not enough we also experience the world consciously through time In fact without a sense of time there would be no consciousness But ironically a complete scientific description of the physical universe would not contain the information as to what time is now So how does this happen Metzinger basically stresses the importance of being able to flag the now as real Being able to differentiate between memories and fantasies and the real world is a huge survival advantage Having a concept of now also allowed us to plan future actions and to compare internal dry runs with given features of the world Again though he stresses that this experienced now is not real in the sense that we normally think it is It is itself a representation Just think about the fact that due to the unavoidable time taken in signal processing and neuronal firing that what you experience as now actually occurred some time in the past3 The reality problem why you were born as a na ve realistIf you solve the one world problem and the now problem all you have is a unified picture of the world and a model of the present moment in time in the brain But consciousness is something You are not aware of these representations or even that they ARE representations you EXPERIENCE these representations as reality Here is where Metzinger s concept of transparency becomes vital For any second order process that occurs at a slower rate than a first order process that first order process will be necessarily transparent to the second order process You watch a film and you see fluid motion in front of you But if the film reel is moving too slowly you become aware of the individual frames and of the illusion of motion that you have been under falls apart Because the processes that creates the contents of your conscious experience are transparent you are constitutionally unable to know they are representations They appear to you as REAL as opposed to what they are just the internal contents of brain function 4 The ineffability problem what we will never be able to talk about Present a person with two very similar shades of green and they will be able to discern a difference between the two colors But show them one of those shades of green again and they will be unable to tell you which one it is We can consciously represent the the difference between colors but are unable to consciously represent the sameness of an individual color Even the subjective experience of certainty is itself only an appearance just an experience and not objective fact because it doesn t exist neuronally This threatens any comprehensive theory of consciousness because if there are no concepts for certain objects in one theory they cannot be reduced to concepts in another one and I don t think Metzinger really answers this issue as much as talks about it for a while unless I missed something 5 The evolution problem what was consciousness good for Consciousness is not cheap from a biological perspective And here Metzinger evokes the global workspace theory by some psychologist who s name evades me at the moment Dan Dennett talks about this in terms of the orienting response or the all hands on deck theory What these ideas all in essence say is that there needs to a process that makes global information available to an organism to further plan motor behavior Whatever might be relevant to a situation needs to be available for processing When you don t know what s going to happen next you need as much relevant information as possible to plan your next move But what WASN T evolutionarily beneficial or efficient would be to create another level of complexity and represent the meta nature of the information It would be way too costly to create a system that informed an organism that a bear representation was present in the brain when all that is needed is to know there is a bear in front of me 6 The who problem what is the entity that has conscious experienceIn the end Metzinger tells us that what we are is in essence a simulation that the organism runs This simulation binds disparate information together and creates a world model flags the now to develop an ongoing experience of now in time is unable to understand the representational nature of the world due to the transparency of the information and has the experience of attending to whatever information is currently in the global workspace Our conscious experience IS the content of the simulation Nothing nothing less We are not our bodies we are not our brains we are not the contents of our walletwe are a simulation that the brain runs to facilitate survival in the world but due to it s nature we are constitutionally unable to know we are simulation This is all in the first third of the book a pretty short book mind you Metzinger goes on to talk about lucid dreaming out of body experiences hallucinogenic drugs and This area of the book gets into the territory you might be familiar with if you read VS Ramachandran or Oliver Sacks But while he seems to wander at times Metzinger always ties these conversations back into his main theory of the Phenomenal Self Model Towards the end he gets into some pretty interesting stuff about ethics and morality as what is ethics but prescriptions about different states of consciousness I can t recommend this book enough I have only two caveats worth mentioning1 This is maybe not the best intro book to consciousness studies It helps to have some background and understanding of neuroscience or psychology or philosophy to really understand the significant nature of the problems Metzinger addresses I think you can probably read the book and enjoy it without this knowledge but knowing how and why these problems are so difficult gives you a finer appreciation for the task Metzinger has set for himself2 He still hasn t REALLY explained subjective experience in my mind But I m too tired to explain why right now Sufficed to say he does the best job out of anyone I ve ever read And he DOES manage to explain the self Right or wrong he certainly doesn t sidestep the issue

Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger

The Ego Tunnel

characters ↠ The Ego Tunnel è PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger T it Do we still have souls free will personal autonomy or moral accountability In a time when the science of cognition is becoming as controversial as evolution The Ego Tunnel provides a stunningly original take on the mystery of the mind. science fiction writers will enjoy this book for the rest of us it s poppycock i ll never get those hours back i felt i HAD to go the distance to be sure of his intent and because the purely fictional uality of the book had me stunned wondering how far his what ifs would go i found out he wants to rule the world through chemistry and clever human boundary stretching even though some current legitimate brain research fueled some of his supportive details most of his chapters were developed off of a truly imaginative world based upon a matrix of air and shadow as can be expected from such nothingness the work serves no one but it certainly does fit into the soon to be demised post modern nonthinking process although to be fair some of his definitions in the first part of the book deserve careful examination and he might seriously consider going back examining those very thoughts and then offering something with well you know actual substance but for this book as it stands now i must ask where are his peer reviews who is vetting his writing he shouldn t be allowed to pass this clap trap off as legitimate scientific process without rigorous examinations by professionals i don t even know what kind of category this non reality based science writing falls under is it fiction is it science fiction what but legitimate non fiction it decidedly is notin addition his boundary stretching ideas are not exactly new since psychedelic experiments came into their own by the 1960s and of course dupont used the slogan better living through chemistry circa 1935 1986 sigh nothing new under the sun but oh what fun it is seeing how stretchy imaginative boundaries can get with all permissions granted through the post modern mind set well writing this book kept him off the streets however it should be noted that beyond the absurdity of his thesis it might be wise to pause and recall the thalidomide birth defects of the late 1950s before we jump on any part of this guy s bandwagon watch out for that cliff buddytechnically this book might be classified as non fiction but i think it deserves a science fiction category so i opted to give it no category it seemed the fairest way to goanother reason i was disappointed in this work is bc i truly was looking for an intelligent exploration of consciousness and the ego now if he takes his early definitions and applies them legitimately not fancifully to consciousness studies and the ego of human nature i might actually want to read that book but at this point i don t trust him to present actual science

Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters

characters ↠ The Ego Tunnel è PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Thomas Metzinger à 5 characters Read & Download ò PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free à Thomas Metzinger El created by our brain an internal image but one we cannot experience as an image Everything we experience is “a virtual self in a virtual reality”But if the self is not “real” why and how did it evolve How does the brain construc. I approached this book thinking it would be an integration of philosophy and neuroscience I was wrong and disappointed Metzinger philosopher by profession seems to explain consciousness as in chiefly philosophical terms supporting his argument by cherry picked cognitive neuroscience findings This cherry picking is what angered me the most especially when combined with the moral high ground from which the author a field of science in which he s not an expert Approved by a philosopher hence it must be true and valid An untested philosophical assumption is not corroborated by neuroscience findings No this can t be the case they re all wrong see part on volition and agency for exampleAnother aspect is something by which I imagine someone without sufficient background or interest in the field could easily by fooled Metzinger analyses and evaluates his theory in great detail but he only ever relates his arguments to his own idea of what he is arguing against Take ualia or the self There is no little man in your head guiding your actions he stresses repeatedly No there isn t Not a single researcher within the field has claimed that for decades This isn t a groundbreaking revelation nor is it busting the myth of the self It s like busting the myth of tooth fairies in a scientific book In short if you are looking for a book on the Science of Consciousness there are other informative books Christof Koch Bernard Baars Stanislas Dehaene and This is not to say they ignore philosophy they don t they synthesise information from different sources critically All in all as much as I enjoyed Metzinger s writing I genuinely did and some of the points the immense confirmation bias is what spoiled it for me

  • Paperback
  • 288
  • The Ego Tunnel
  • Thomas Metzinger
  • en
  • 20 July 2020
  • 9780465020690